From Idea Overload to Innovation Engine: Building Origin Spice’s Product Idea Intake Process

Here at Origin Spice, we’re practically buzzing with excitement as we develop our first product. After our concept and scoping phase review, our vision of bringing ethically sourced, small-batch spices to modern kitchens is coming to life. But with success comes a whole new challenge—we’re being flooded with brilliant ideas from every direction!

Don’t get me wrong; this is a good problem. It means our team is engaged, our stakeholders are invested, and creativity is flowing. But without a structured way to capture and evaluate all this input, we risk drowning in possibilities rather than being propelled by them.

Sound familiar? If you’re nodding along, you’ve probably experienced what we call “idea overload” – that overwhelming sensation when suggestions come at you from Slack messages, hallway conversations, formal meetings, and late-night emails. Before you know it, you’ve got product ideas scribbled on napkins and buried in meeting notes, with no systematic way to organize or evaluate them.

The Warning Signs of Idea Chaos

We realized we needed a better system when we started noticing these red flags:

⚠️ Ideas coming from everywhere in every format – Slack messages, emails, hallway conversations, meeting asides, and even social media DMs. Nothing was centralized or documented consistently.

⚠️ Hours spent just organizing input – Our product team was spending valuable time just trying to make sense of all the suggestions before they could even begin evaluating them.

⚠️ Team morale is taking a hit – Without a clear process, people felt their ideas were being ignored or forgotten, while others were frustrated by constant interruptions and changing priorities.

⚠️ Losing sight of our strategy – With so many exciting possibilities, we found ourselves tempted by shiny new ideas that didn’t necessarily align with our core mission and strategy.

Building Our Idea Intake System from the Ground Up

Over the past month, we’ve been implementing a structured approach to idea management that maintains our collaborative culture while adding much-needed organization. Here’s how we’re doing it:

1. Creating a Single Source of Truth

First, we established a central repository for all product ideas. After evaluating several options, we settled on a dedicated Notion database that integrates with our existing tools. This gives us:

Now, whenever an idea emerges – whether it’s during a customer interview or while someone’s cooking dinner – there’s one place it needs to go.

2. Standardizing the Submission Process

We created a simple idea submission form that asks:

This structure helps submitters think critically about their ideas before submission and provides our evaluation team with consistent information. The form takes less than five minutes to complete but dramatically improves the quality of submissions.

3. Establishing Clear Evaluation Criteria

Not all ideas are created equal, and we needed a transparent way to evaluate them. We developed a scoring system based on:

Each idea receives a composite score that helps us prioritize objectively, rather than based on who shouted loudest or most recently.

4. Setting Realistic Review Cadences

We now have a bi-weekly idea review meeting with our cross-functional product council. This regular cadence means that no idea sits unaddressed for more than two weeks, while still giving us focused time between reviews to execute on our current priorities.

For urgent ideas that can’t wait for the regular cycle, we’ve established an exception process—but we’re careful to ensure that “urgent” doesn’t become the new normal.

The Crucial Difference Between Ideas and Feedback

One important distinction we’ve made is between product ideas and product feedback:

Product ideas are suggestions for new features, products, or significant changes to existing offerings. These go through our full intake process.

Product feedback is commentary on existing features or user experiences that helps us refine what we’ve already built. This flows through our customer feedback channels.

Making this distinction has helped us direct input to the appropriate channels and set proper expectations for response times and action.

Setting Expectations with Contributors

Perhaps the most challenging part of implementing any new process is managing expectations. We’ve been transparent with our team about:

We’ve found that people generally understand constraints as long as the process is transparent and they know their input has been genuinely considered.

Empowering Self-Service Updates

To reduce the administrative burden on our product team, we’ve made our idea tracking system accessible to everyone in the organization. Contributors can check the status of their submissions, see evaluation notes, and understand where their idea fits in the broader prioritization landscape.

This self-service approach has reduced follow-up questions by approximately 70% while increasing overall satisfaction with the process.

Early Results Are Promising

We’re just a month into our new process, but we’re already seeing significant improvements:

The Path Forward

As we continue to refine our product idea intake process, we’re learning that the right balance of structure and flexibility is key. Too rigid, and we risk stifling the creative energy that makes Origin Spice special. Too loose, and we’re back to idea chaos.

Building a successful product-led growth engine requires both innovation and discipline. By creating clear channels for ideas while maintaining focus on our strategic priorities, we’re setting ourselves up to develop products that truly resonate with our customers.

If you’re facing similar challenges in your organization, start small. Even a simple shared document with basic evaluation criteria is better than nothing. Over time, you can evolve your process to match your team’s specific needs and culture.

And remember – the goal isn’t to reduce the number of ideas. It’s to create a system that can effectively capture, evaluate, and implement the best ones while keeping your team sane in the process.

How does your organization handle product ideas? We’d love to hear about your experiences in the comments below!

Looking for more insights on building products people love? Subscribe to our newsletter for monthly updates on Origin Spice’s journey from concept to kitchen.