How the death of predictable marketing mirrors the spice trade crisis – and what ancient wisdom teaches us about modern customer acquisition

I had a revelation at a farmers’ market last weekend.

Standing at a spice vendor’s booth, watching a grandmother from Gujarat explain the difference between two types of cardamom to a curious millennial, I realized we’re witnessing the same crisis plaguing every industry: the death of authentic connection.

Just like B2B leaders are panicking about pipeline generation in our oversaturated digital world, food brands are struggling with a harsh reality: 73% of home cooks have expired spices sitting in their cabinets, yet they’re more disconnected from their ingredients than ever before.

We’ve Been Living in a Food Fantasy Too

For the past 15 years, the food industry rode the same wave as SaaS companies:

• Cheap capital funding massive D2C plays
• Unlimited shelf space through e-commerce
• Consumers with time to discover new brands
• Markets that weren’t saturated with “artisanal” everything

Those days are over. Dead and buried.

NOW? Every spice blend has 47 competitors on Amazon. Instagram food influencers get 500 pitch emails per week. Your customers are drowning in subscription box options, meal kit advertisements, and “authentic” products that taste like cardboard.

Sound familiar? It should. Because whether you’re selling software or saffron, you’re fighting for the same scarce resource: human attention.

The Spice Trade Knew Something We Forgot

Here’s what’s fascinating about our journey building Origin Spice: the most valuable lessons came from studying how spices were actually traded for thousands of years.

Spices weren’t sold through funnels or conversion optimization. They were traded through relationships, stories, and direct human connection.

A Persian saffron trader didn’t succeed by sending 47 LinkedIn messages to Venetian merchants. He succeeded by:

• Actually being useful: Sharing knowledge about cultivation, harvest timing, and proper storage
• Physical presence: Traveling dangerous routes to meet customers in person
• Community building: Creating trusted networks of buyers and sellers
• Authentic storytelling: Connecting each grain of saffron to its origin story

Sounds like a more effective go-to-market strategy than most Series B startups? That’s because it is.

Strategy #1: Join the Conversation (Don’t Start One)

When we launched Origin Spice, we could have done what every food startup does: hire a growth marketing agency, pump money into Facebook ads, and hope for 3x ROAS.

Instead, we did something radical: we joined existing conversations.

I started showing up to cooking forums, not to pitch our subscription service, but to answer genuine questions:

• “What’s the difference between Ceylon and Cassia cinnamon?”
• “Why does my turmeric taste like dirt?”
• “How do I know if my cardamom pods are fresh?”

No pitches. No calendar links. Just useful answers.

You know what happened? People started asking where they could get the spices I was describing. Not because I was selling, but because I was genuinely helpful.

Impact on CAC: Practically zero. But the trust and authority we built became our most valuable marketing asset.

Strategy #2: Remember Food Is Physical

While every other food brand was optimizing their Shopify checkout flow, we did something counterintuitive: we got physical.

We started showing up at farmers’ markets. Not with a booth selling our subscription boxes, but with a small table offering spice education:

• Free spice tastings with origin stories
• Hands-on grinding demonstrations
• Conversations about traditional uses in different cultures

The CFO moment: “We’re spending $3,000 per market for… education?”

The results: At one market in Austin, we had 47 people sign up for our newsletter, and 12 converted to paid subscribers within two weeks. More importantly, those customers had a 94% retention rate because they understood the why behind what we were doing.

Compare that to our digital ads: higher acquisition cost, lower conversion rate, and 67% churn after three months.

The Airbnb Moment for Food

Remember how Airbnb’s founders personally visited every host in New York, taking professional photos and building relationships? Everyone called it “unscalable.”

But that’s precisely what made it work.

We had our own version when Tessa flew to a small cinnamon farm in Sri Lanka. Not for a photo op or marketing content, but to understand the actual process, meet the farmers, and learn their challenges.

That one trip led to:

• Our most authentic supplier relationship
• Stories that customers still share on social media
• A quality standard that none of our competitors can match
• Customer loyalty that survived three price increases

Cost: $4,500 for the trip. Value: Immeasurable brand authenticity and customer connection.

The Hard Truth About Food CAC

Just like in B2B, the Customer Acquisition Cost in the food industry is increasing. Permanently.

But here’s what we learned from the spice trade: the solution isn’t better funnels or smarter targeting. It’s becoming genuinely useful to people who don’t want to buy from you yet.

The Persian saffron trader didn’t optimize his conversion rate. He became so knowledgeable, so helpful, and so trustworthy that when someone needed saffron, there was only one person to call.

What This Means for Every Food Brand

The companies winning in 2025 won’t be the ones with the best growth hacks or the slickest Instagram ads. They’ll be the ones whose founders:

• Join communities where their customers naturally gather (cooking forums, local food groups, cultural communities)
• Show up physically at markets, events, and tastings
• Become genuinely helpful by sharing knowledge, not just products
• Build genuine relationships instead of optimizing email sequences

The Bottom Line

The old playbooks are dead. Whether you’re selling software or sumac, mass marketing to strangers is becoming impossible and expensive.

What works now is the same thing that worked 500 years ago: getting out there, meeting people, and being genuinely helpful to the humans you want to serve.

It’s not scalable in the traditional sense. It requires founders to leave their laptops and engage with the world like human beings.

But it’s the only thing that consistently works right now.

The food brands winning in 2025 aren’t the ones with the best conversion optimization or the most innovative targeting algorithms. They’re the ones whose leaders are willing to get on planes, visit farms, join communities, and remember that food is fundamentally about people nourishing people.

---

Tessa Blizinski is our Creative Director at Origin Spice, where ancient spice wisdom meets modern technology. When she’s not traveling to remote farms or perfecting spice blends, she can be found at farmers markets sharing stories about the incredible people who grow our food.